There’s something about Donald Trump and jokes that never quite feel like just jokes. This week, only 100 days into his second term as president, Trump made another one of those strange comments that sound funny at first — until you stop and really think about it.
A reporter asked Trump who he thinks should be the next pope after Pope Francis. Without missing a beat, Trump smiled and said, “I’d like to be pope. That’d be my No. 1 choice.”
Reporter: Who do you want to be the next Pope?
Trump: “I’d like to be Pope. That’d be my number one choice.”🤡 pic.twitter.com/gTIUBhXjMG
— Republicans against Trump (@RpsAgainstTrump) April 29, 2025
People laughed. Of course they did. It’s not every day that a U.S. president — especially one who isn’t Catholic — says he wants to be pope. But if you’ve followed Trump over the years, you might understand why some people weren’t laughing. Because this is how it often starts with him. First, it’s a joke. Then later… maybe it’s not.
Stay up-to-date with the latest news!
Subscribe and start recieving our daily emails.
He followed up with a more serious answer: “I don’t have a preference. I might say we have a cardinal that happens to be out of a place called New York who is very good.”
He was talking about Cardinal Timothy Dolan, the Archbishop of New York. That part sounded more grounded. But the damage was already done. The internet had grabbed hold of the “Pope Donald” moment, and the reactions were loud.
Below are some of the reactions:
Now he wants to be the next pope, God help us. pic.twitter.com/1VChIzdagI
— 𝐀𝐧𝐧𝐚 𝐊𝐎𝐌𝐒𝐀 | 🇪🇺🇫🇷🇵🇱🇺🇦 (@tweet4Anna_NAFO) April 29, 2025
Donald Trump wants to be Pope now? The only holy thing about him is the golf swing he cheats on. He thinks “Cardinal” is just a baseball team.
This ain’t outreach to Catholics—it’s a cry for help in Latin. Next stop: Saint Don of Mar-a-Lago. 🤡✝️🍷 pic.twitter.com/sP4BPWdnIc— Russell Drew (@RussOnPolitics) April 29, 2025
I hate to say it but we Catholics live by rules that he hasn’t followed. lol that would be a no go on the pope. First you have to be a good person. Second being a rapist wouldn’t help. Adultery wouldn’t help either. I’m going to just stop there
— Emmeline (@momof3tired) April 29, 2025
I think the prerequisite is “need to be able to go into a church without bursting into flames”
— TheGeekReborn (@thegeekreborn) April 29, 2025
Trump. Does. Not. Joke.
— Janice Hough (@leftcoastbabe) April 29, 2025
The man who’s been indicted multiple times, paid hush money, and spreads hate daily wants to be Pope. We’ve officially crossed into divine comedy territory – minus the divine, just pure clownery.
— Tetїana 🇺🇦 (@TPSpindel) April 29, 2025
But underneath the memes and laughter, a fundamental question began to form: Why does this feel familiar?
The answer lies in Trump’s pattern. He often floats strange ideas. He says them lightly like he’s joking. But over time, we’ve seen many of those ideas become part of his actual plans — or at least serious talking points. Remember Greenland? Trump once said he wanted to buy it. People thought it was a joke. Then we learned he had asked his team if it was possible.
Or when he suggested running for more than two terms — something that breaks U.S. tradition and the Constitution. He’s never completely ruled it out, and some of his supporters even chant for it at rallies.
He once even said that Canada could be America’s 51st state. Again, people laughed. But that idea, too, turned into honest policy conversations about how closely we control the northern border.
So now, when he says he wants to be pope, it’s not just about religion. It’s about testing limits. Seeing what people will accept.
Now, let’s step back. Can Donald Trump really become the pope? No. Only a baptized Catholic man — usually a cardinal — can be chosen. And the choice doesn’t come from voters or campaigns. It originates from a group of Catholic cardinals in a secret meeting known as a conclave. They vote until someone wins two-thirds support. Then they announce it to the world with white smoke from a Vatican chimney.
It’s a quiet, sacred process. Nothing like American elections. And nothing like Trump.
Featured image via Screengrab