DISCLAIMER: This article was first published on August 29, 2024
In what can only be described as a political disaster, JD Vance faced a hostile reception at the IAFF (International Association of Fire Fighters) union conference, with boos echoing through the room as he struggled to connect with his audience of firefighters and first responders. The event, held just a day after Minnesota Governor Tim Walz received a warm welcome at the same conference, highlighted the stark contrast between the two politiciansโ approaches and their ability to resonate with working-class Americans.
Sounds like we got some fans and some haters, thatโs okay, letโs listen to what I have to say here, and Iโll make my pitch here.
~JD Vance
A retired paramedic, who was present during Vanceโs speech, took to Twitter to express his embarrassment at Vanceโs performance, noting how the Ohio Senatorโs attempts to rally support among first responders fell flat. The paramedic pointed out that public safety workers typically lean center-right and could have been a natural base for Vance. However, the applause lines were met with tepid responses, and at several points, the crowd even booed Vance, signaling a disconnect between the candidate and his audience.
Iโm going to drop out of character a moment here on Twitter to say that I am listening to JD Vance live addressing IAFF Firefighters at the IAFF union convention. It is embarrassing. Iโm a 15 year retired urban Paramedic and he should be able to get the support /x
โ Harvest Corn Dog (@HarvestCornDog) August 29, 2024
Stay up-to-date with the latest news!
Subscribe and start recieving our daily emails.
One particularly tone-deaf moment occurred when Vance suggested that funds should be allocated to building new firehouses instead of migrant sheltersโa line that, instead of galvanizing support, only received lukewarm applause. The audience, made up of individuals who regularly respond to humanitarian crises, seemed unimpressed by Vanceโs simplistic political rhetoric that failed to address the complex realities they face daily.
Are they booing JD Vance?? pic.twitter.com/SHM6LlzXlJ
โ Acyn (@Acyn) August 29, 2024
The cringeworthy moments didnโt stop there. Vance also tried to score points by attacking COVID-19 vaccine mandates, promising that a Trump/Vance administration would protect โfree speechโ by not imposing such mandates in the future. This attempt to pander to the crowd once again fell flat, with the audience responding with little enthusiasm. The retired paramedicโs tweets summed up the atmosphere in the room: Vance sounded fake, out of touch, and more interested in scoring political points than addressing the real concerns of first responders.
Do Not Expect A Union Friendly President
JD Vanceโs claim that he and Donald Trump are โpro-workerโ is starkly contradicted by their track record, particularly Trumpโs aggressive actions against collective bargaining and unions. Trumpโs administration took numerous steps to weaken the rights of workers to organize and engage in collective bargaining, which is the cornerstone of union power. For instance, the Trump-appointed National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) systematically rolled back protections for workers, making it more difficult for unions to represent their members effectively. This included overturning rules that streamlined the union election process and undermining workersโ access to essential information during union organizing campaignsโ.
Additionally, Trump issued executive orders that directly attacked federal unions by limiting their ability to negotiate on behalf of employees and reducing the time union representatives could spend helping workers with grievances. His administrationโs actions, such as supporting โright to workโ laws and rescinding policies that required employers to disclose anti-union activities, further illustrate a clear hostility towards unionsโ.
Given these actions, the idea that Trump and Vance could be โpro-unionโ is misleading at best. Their policies not only undermine collective bargainingโthe very heart of union activitiesโbut also favor corporate interests over the rights and well-being of workers. This contradiction highlights the disingenuousness of their pro-worker rhetoric.
Vance: Now, President Trump and I are proud to be the most pro-worker Republican ticket in history and I want to talk about why weโre fighting for working people .. why weโre going to fight for unions and non-union alike.
Crowd: Audible boos
JD Vance: President Trump and I are proud to be the most pro-worker Republican ticket in history.
Crowd: Booooooo pic.twitter.com/InKPhT3TRw
โ Acyn (@Acyn) August 29, 2024