Since Trump returned to office, Democrats have flipped 31 state legislative seats, while Republicans have yet to flip one in the opposite direction.
The latest came Tuesday in Pennsylvania’s 12th House District, a seat Trump carried by 18 points less than two years ago.
Brandon Dukes, a loan administrator from Butler County, edged Republican Scott Timko by 8,434 votes to 8,346, winning by just 88 votes. The margin was small enough to attract attention but not small enough to trigger Pennsylvania’s automatic recount threshold. Republicans had held the seat since 1999.
Scott Presler was quick to react, writing on X: “It appears Republicans will lose the special election in Butler County, PA, by 88 votes.”
It appears Republicans will lose the special election in Butler County, PA, by 88 votes. pic.twitter.com/HZPZuyUUOY
— ThePersistence (@ScottPresler) August 19, 2026
Stay up-to-date with the latest news!
Subscribe and start recieving our daily emails.
Democratic Gov. Josh Shapiro was happy to place the result in a much larger frame. “Pennsylvanians are rising up and using their power to combat the chaos, cruelty, and corruption, and we’re not slowing down,” he said. Dukes offered a more local explanation, pointing to complaints about road construction and a message focused on practical issues. “We kept it local, we kept it practical, and we kept it common sense,” he said.
Brandon Dukes just flipped a state House District in Butler County — a seat Trump carried by 18 points and the GOP state rep won by 30 points in 2024.
Pennsylvanians are rising up and using their power to combat the chaos, cruelty, and corruption — and we’re not slowing down.…
— Josh Shapiro (@JoshShapiroPA) August 19, 2026
For now, the victory gives Democrats a 103-100 majority in the state House.
Dukes and Timko will face each other again in November for the full two-year term, when turnout should be far higher than Tuesday’s roughly 16,800 voters. That represented barely a third of the district’s registered electorate.
Still, the result carries more significance because of the district’s recent history. Republicans have now lost the seat twice within four years, first at the top of the ticket and now in a down-ballot race.
And Pennsylvania is only one piece of the larger picture.
The Downballot’s tracking counts Tuesday’s result as the 31st state legislative flip since Trump’s second inauguration, with every one moving from Republican to Democratic control. Across 110 special elections since January 2025, Democratic candidates have beaten Kamala Harris’s 2024 performance by an average of 12.5 points and Joe Biden’s 2020 result by 8.4 points. That is even stronger than 2018, the midterm cycle that cost Republicans 41 House seats and their majority.
The pattern has also spread across the country.
Iowa produced two of the 31 flips, while Mississippi changed three seats on the same day last November. Texas Senate District 9 went Democratic in January, followed by two Florida seats in March. The list now stretches well beyond the districts either party might have considered vulnerable when the year began.
Both parties see the results through their own lens.
DNC spokesperson Jaelin O’Halloran pointed to rising costs, saying Republicans created “a toxic midterm environment for themselves” by driving up prices for “everything from gas to groceries to healthcare,” while RNC spokesperson Natalie Baldassarre dismissed that argument, saying Republicans are “united, on offense, and armed with the largest war chest in party history.”
Featured image courtesy of Newsweek
