Trump had two things going on in the Oval Office Monday, a genuine tribute to a teenager, and an index card telling him how to deliver it.
Ryder Williams, 16, and Nathaniel Rai, 10, were the reason for the visit. Williams had pulled Nathaniel from a rip current at a Santa Cruz beach in July, and Trump handed him a signed certificate, calling him a “young American hero.”
The praise sounded sincere. “We’re honored to have all of you. And again, what you did was incredible,” Trump said. “And everybody saw it. And you’d watch it over and over. I know when I first saw it, I said, ‘Roll that back, I want to see that again. Is that really happening?'”
AMAZING: President Trump to HEROIC California lifeguard Ryder Williams who saved 10-year-old boy, Nathaniel Rai: “What you did was incredible and everybody saw it… I know when I first saw it, I said, ‘roll that back, I want to see that again. Is that really happening?’”
⁰“The… pic.twitter.com/6mj5Lzq4ma— RedWave Press (@RedWavePress) August 17, 2026
A close-up photo from the meeting caught what he was holding the whole time. It was a curled card with photos of both boys, a few lines of background on each, and his own schedule for the visit, right down to “1:15 p.m. Photo Opportunity” and “1:30 p.m. POTUS concludes.”
Here’s a close up of the card President Trump was holding during the Oval Office event from REUTERS/Kylie Cooper pic.twitter.com/BdQINDLIVc
— Acyn (@Acyn) August 17, 2026
Stay up-to-date with the latest news!
Subscribe and start recieving our daily emails.
Trump’s own team spent years turning this exact prop into a punchline when Biden used one.
Stephen Miller, then a senior Trump advisor, criticized Biden after a March 2021 press conference where he was photographed with a card listing which reporters to call on. “It was not very reassuring today that Biden relied so heavily on generic notes from staff to discuss the growing threat from China,” Miller told Newsweek.
Trump himself described that same press conference as “very sad” and “ridiculous” in a Fox News interview.
Candace Owens took it further on X. “Joe Biden had a cheat sheet with the names and faces marked of which journalists to call on, and he knew EXACTLY what questions would be asked of him. That was not a press conference—that was a play put on by bad faith actors in a pseudo-democracy.”
Joe Biden had a cheat sheet with the names and faces marked of which journalists to call on, and he knew EXACTLY what questions would be asked of him.
That was not a press conference—that was a play put on by bad faith actors in a pseudo-democracy. pic.twitter.com/ee56Xcg63M
— Candace Owens (@RealCandaceO) March 26, 2021
A year later, Biden’s card got even more specific, reportedly instructing him “YOU take YOUR seat” and “YOU depart.”
Sean Hannity responded with “HOLY SHEET! Biden’s Presidential Cheat Sheet Leaks Online, Reminds Him to Sit Down.” Benny Johnson added his own read, writing that “next time someone tries to tell you Joe Biden isn’t a geriatric nursing home patient trapped in the White House, show them this. He needs a notecard with step by step directions telling him what to do, including ‘YOU take YOUR seat.'”
The White House doesn’t think the comparison holds up this time.
Asked about it, a spokesperson pushed back on equating “Joe Biden using cheat sheets with hand-picked reporters and their presubmitted questions with President Trump using a notecard to know the biographies of his Oval Office guests.”
That same visit produced something else entirely that got just as much attention.
Trump turned from the boys mid-interview to confront CNN’s Kristen Holmes, telling her, “You’re very disrespectful in front of this young man, okay?” Then he turned to Williams directly. “Don’t you find her disrespectful?” Williams didn’t say anything. Trump kept going, calling Holmes “a loud, boisterous person” and “a fake reporter” who “report[s] fake news.”
🗣️ Trump lashes out at CNN reporter over Kim Jong-un question
💢 US President Donald Trump repeatedly tells CNN chief correspondent Kristen Holmes to ‘be quiet,’ calling her ‘very disrespectful’ and a ‘fake reporter’ as she asks about his contact with North Korean leader… pic.twitter.com/adn9m02BZF
— Anadolu English (@anadoluagency) August 18, 2026
Featured image via X screengrab